Most free VPNs are not safe. A small number of free VPNs from trusted companies are fine for light use. The rest range from careless with your data to outright dangerous. The difference comes down to how the service pays its bills.
A VPN routes your internet traffic through an encrypted tunnel run by the provider. That means the provider can see a great deal about what you do online. With a paid VPN, you pay for the service. With a free VPN, someone else has to pay. Often, that someone is an advertiser buying your browsing data.
This guide explains how free VPNs make money, the real risks, when one is acceptable, and which safer free options exist.
How Free VPNs Make Money
Running a VPN is expensive. Servers, bandwidth, staff and security audits all cost real money. A company that charges you nothing still has to cover those costs. Here are the main ways free VPNs pay for themselves.
Selling your data. This is the most common model. A free VPN sits in a privileged position on your device. It can see the websites you visit, your location and your device details. Some free VPNs collect this information, package it into user profiles and sell it to data brokers and advertisers. The privacy tool becomes the thing that invades your privacy.
Advertising and tracking libraries. Many free VPN apps show adverts inside the app. To serve targeted adverts, they add third party tracking code. These libraries can collect far more than an advert needs. Some have been caught reading device details and building profiles for advertisers.
Upselling you to a paid plan. This is the honest model. The free tier is a limited version of a paid product. It exists to show you the service and encourage an upgrade. The company earns money from paying customers, so it does not need to sell your data. Free tiers from Proton VPN, Windscribe and TunnelBear work this way.
Peer to peer networks. A few services turn your device into part of their network. Your internet connection gets rented out to other users. This was the model used by Hola VPN in the past. It means strangers can route traffic through your device and your IP address. Avoid any VPN that works this way.
Malware and botnets. In the worst cases, the app is not a real VPN at all. In May 2024, the US Department of Justice and the FBI dismantled the 911 S5 botnet, which had hijacked 19 million devices across more than 190 countries. Investigators identified at least 18 free VPN apps as the main way the malware spread. The apps included MaskVPN, DewVPN, PaladinVPN, ProxyGate, ShieldVPN and ShineVPN.
The Risks of Using a Free VPN
Free VPNs carry several risks that paid services from reputable companies usually avoid. Here are the main ones.
1. Your data is logged and sold
A no logs policy means the VPN does not record what you do online. Many free VPNs either have no such policy or have one that is full of exceptions. If a VPN logs your activity and sells it, you have swapped your internet provider for a less regulated company that profits from your data. Your internet provider in the UK is regulated. A random free VPN company based overseas often is not.
2. Weak or missing encryption
A VPN is supposed to encrypt your traffic. Many free VPNs use outdated protocols or, in some cases, do not encrypt your traffic at all. A study by CSIRO, the Australian national science agency, examined 283 Android VPN apps. It found that 38 per cent contained malware or malvertising, 84 per cent leaked user traffic and 18 per cent did not encrypt traffic at all. With no encryption, your internet provider and anyone on the same public Wi-Fi network can still see what you do.
3. Malware in the app
Antivirus tools flagged around 20 per cent of the 100 free Android VPN apps in a Top10VPN investigation as potentially harmful. Fake VPN apps are a known way to spread malware on phones. Security researchers at Koi Security also found a Chrome VPN extension with more than 100,000 installs that had been updated to include spyware like behaviour. The app store listing looked normal. The update was the problem.
4. Data leaks
A VPN can leak your real IP address or your DNS requests even while it appears to be working. In the Top10VPN investigation of 100 free Android VPN apps, nearly 90 per cent leaked some form of user data. A leaking VPN gives you a false sense of security. You believe you are protected when you are not.
5. Intrusive adverts and browser hijacking
Some free VPNs inject adverts into the pages you visit. Others change your browser settings, redirect your searches or open pop ups. This is annoying at best. At worst, it is a sign that the app has deeper control over your device than a VPN should need.
6. Slow speeds and data caps
Free VPNs often limit how much data you can use each month, commonly between 2 GB and 10 GB. They also tend to run fewer servers, so speeds drop when many users connect at once. This is a minor problem compared with the privacy risks, but it makes a free VPN a poor choice for streaming or large downloads.
When Is a Free VPN Acceptable?
A free VPN can be acceptable in narrow situations. The key test is whether the free tier comes from a reputable company with a paid product, an independent audit and a clear no logs policy.
A trustworthy free tier is fine for light, occasional use. Reading the news on public Wi-Fi, checking email at a cafe or hiding your IP address from a website are reasonable uses. For these tasks, a limited free plan from Proton VPN, Windscribe or TunnelBear is a sensible choice.
A free VPN is not a good choice for regular use, sensitive work or anything where your privacy really matters. If you use a VPN every day, handle work documents or want to keep your browsing private from your internet provider, a paid VPN from a reputable provider is worth the small monthly cost. Paid plans usually cost less than a coffee per month on a longer plan.
If you only need a VPN for public Wi-Fi, a free tier from a trusted company is often enough. For a deeper look at staying safe on shared networks, read our guide on how to stay safe on public Wi-Fi. A VPN is only one layer of protection. Strong, unique passwords matter just as much, which is why a password manager for beginners is a good companion to any VPN.
Never use a random free VPN for banking, work logins or anything involving personal data. If the VPN is free and you cannot find a real company, an audit or a privacy policy behind it, assume your data is the product.
Safer Free Options and What to Check
Not every free VPN is a trap. A few free tiers come from companies that also sell paid plans, publish independent audits and keep their apps open source. These are the exceptions worth knowing.
Proton VPN Free. Unlimited data, no adverts and no logs. Proton is based in Switzerland, publishes independent audits and uses the same infrastructure as its paid plans. The free tier limits which servers you can use, but it does not limit how much data you use.
Windscribe Free. Around 10 to 15 GB of data per month, depending on whether you confirm your email address. Windscribe has been independently audited and follows a no logs policy. The free tier uses the same encryption as the paid plan.
TunnelBear Free. A small monthly allowance of around 500 MB. TunnelBear is audited every year by the security firm Cure53 and is known for clear, plain English privacy policies. It is best for very occasional use.
PrivadoVPN Free. Around 10 GB per month with no logs and the same AES-256 encryption as the paid plan. It is a smaller company than Proton, so check its audit record before you rely on it.
Before you install any free VPN, run through this checklist:
- Find the company. A real company name, a real website and a real address. If you cannot find who runs it, do not install it.
- Read the privacy policy. Look for a clear no logs statement. Vague wording about collecting data to improve the service is a warning sign.
- Look for an independent audit. Reputable VPNs pay outside security firms to check their no logs claims. No audit means no proof.
- Check the permissions. A VPN needs permission to set up a network tunnel. It does not need access to your contacts, photos or messages. Top10VPN found that nearly 70 per cent of free Android VPN apps requested permissions with no legitimate VPN use case.
- Check the reviews carefully. Fake reviews are common for free VPN apps. Look for detailed reviews that mention specific problems, and check independent testing sites rather than the app store alone.
- Avoid VPNs that promise too much. No free VPN can offer unlimited everything, every server location and total anonymity for nothing. If it sounds too good to be true, it is.
FAQs
Are free VPNs safe to use on public Wi-Fi?
A free VPN from a trusted company is safer than no VPN on public Wi-Fi. A random free VPN can be worse than no VPN at all, because it can log and sell your data. Use a free tier from Proton VPN, Windscribe or TunnelBear if you need one.
Can a free VPN steal my passwords?
A VPN can see your traffic if it is not encrypted by the website itself. Most websites now use HTTPS, which encrypts your login details between your browser and the site. A malicious VPN could still see which sites you visit and, in rare cases, inject content into pages. This is why the company behind the VPN matters so much.
Is using a free VPN legal in the UK?
Yes. Using a VPN is legal in the UK. A VPN does not make illegal activity legal. Downloading copyrighted material without permission or accessing banned content is still unlawful whether or not you use a VPN.
Why does CISA advise against personal VPNs?
CISA, the US cybersecurity agency, said in its December 2024 mobile security guidance: “Do not use a personal VPN. Personal VPNs simply shift residual risks from your ISP to the VPN provider, often increasing the attack surface.” The point is that a VPN moves your trust from your internet provider to the VPN company. If that company is less trustworthy than your provider, you have made things worse.
Should I pay for a VPN instead?
If you use a VPN every day or care about your privacy, yes. A paid plan from an audited provider with a clear no logs policy costs a few pounds a month. It removes data caps, gives you faster speeds and means the company earns money from you rather than from your data.
Conclusion
Most free VPNs are not safe. The research is clear. Independent testing has found data leaks, weak encryption and even malware in a large share of free VPN apps. The 911 S5 botnet showed how dangerous a bad free VPN can be.
That does not mean every free VPN is a scam. Free tiers from Proton VPN, Windscribe and TunnelBear are genuinely safe because they are limited versions of paid products from audited companies. The company behind the VPN is what matters, not the price tag.
If you need a VPN, start with a trusted free tier for occasional use. If you use one every day, pay for it. A few pounds a month is a small price for a service that does not treat your browsing history as its business model.
